Homepage / Psychology / Pantheism, Monotheism, Atheism, And Communication
Google Helpouts – A Help Provider’s Review How Much Water Should I Drink Every Day? Installing Google Wallet on Android Outside the United States Q: Is Spirituality the Opposite of Science? A: Definitely not How to Remove io9’s Space Wasting Sidebar I’d be Leery of Google Keep, Google’s Evernote Competitor FUD and Sensationalism from F-Secure on Android Malware Numbers The Definition of Irony in Web Design Weight Loss Status Update, Day 120 Weight Loss Status Update, Day 60 Weight Loss Status Update, Day 30 Weight Loss & Unconventional Eating Habits Weight Loss Problems Despite Following All the Conventional Wisdom How Strategic Voting Subverts Democracy Response to Vic Toews’ Email re Bill C-30 Privacy Concerns One Million Moms protests sexuality of JC Penny’s new spokesperson Ellen DeGeneres Review: Samsung Sidekick 4G From T-Mobile GoDaddy’s Stance On SOPA Shows Off Their Ignorance In More Ways Than One! Android 472% Malware Increase Scare Is Sensationalist Fix VSFTPD Slow Directory Listings & Timeouts Tablet Computing: Apple Only? Using Linux to Root the Sidekick 4G (Samsung Galaxy Series SGH -T839) Linux Tip: Permanently Disable NumPad Mouse Keys Google Music releases Linux Music Manager! Migrating Openfire Instant Messaging Service PBX In A Flash: Custom Dialplans & FreePBX Android App Review: Remote Desktop For Your Phone! PBX In A Flash: Send Email Using Gmail / Google Apps Android Security Apps Review: Lookout, SeekDroid, Cerberus, Prey & Theft Aware How To Get Amazon’s Free Android Apps From Outside The US Google Music Beta Impressions (vs Subsonic) Swype & SwiftKeyX Android Virtual Keyboards Review Why You Can’t Just Tell Your Computer What You Want It To Do Cellphone Use Is NOT Giving You Cancer Facebook Messages Offering “Unprecedented”? Um, No… Etsy: Great Community Care & Responsiveness! Etsy: Now Worse Than Facebook For Respecting User Privacy? Android: Major Malware Killed Fast & Clean Facebook’s Privacy Breaches And Plans On Exposing More Personal Info Facebook’s New “Like”: Instead Of You, Websites Get To Post Why You Like Them Is Mexico Safe To Visit? Definitely! Cost Of Living In Bucerias CRTC Backpedals On Allowing False News Broadcasting! Facebook: Now With Even Less Social Networking! Pro CRTC Amendment 2010-931 Arguments & Responses How To Install Carrier-Blocked Android Apps Without Rooting Your Phone Take Action On The CRTC’s Amendments To Allow News Broadcasters To Report Opinions Or Lies As Facts Ninjerktsu’s “Carl Sagan and his Fully Armed Spaceship of the Imagination” As A Single Image Puerto Vallarta & Area: Tips For Snowbirds Bucerias: A Snowbird’s Impressions Facebook: Why The Sudden Monetization Push? Facebook Outrage Du Jour: Your Posts Can Be Sold For Ads Handy Android App: FilesAnywhere, A Fax For Your Phone Facebook Apps Can Now Access Your Address & Mobile Number Diaspora – My Impressions Two Months In First Beach Day of 2011, in Bucerias! Handy Android App: Google Voice Callback Free Swype Touchscreen Keyboard For Android Signal Strength Drop – iPhone 4 vs Droid Facebook Privacy & Security Tips Making Google Voice Work After Moving To Canada Implanted Contact Lenses – Best $5000 I *EVER* Spent! Quantum Darwinism! Pantheism, Monotheism, Atheism, And Communication

Psychology, Random Thoughts, Religion

Pantheism, Monotheism, Atheism, And Communication

Just had a random thunk I had while reading an article on peoples who have remained completely isolated from mainstream human culture.  What crossed my mind was that the more primitive a religion is, the easier it is to communicate aspects of your unobservable inner life to others using religious analogs.  So perhaps the more abstract a religion becomes, the more it’s adherents tend to introspection and analytical thinking.  Perhaps this is why monastaries and the like have always been associated with higher learning and academic pursuits, and why atheists generally wind up being more intelligent than the religious – they don’t have nearly the number of token analogs the religious have to communicate their inner states!So.

While primitive religions tend to personify natural events, they also tend to personify archetypes of human behaviour. You can most easily see this in Greek and Roman mythology, where we have Zeus hurling lightning bolts and controlling the rains as a weather god, and yet the Greeks also had Athena, personifying the very human characteristic of wisdom1.

Anyway, pantheism such as this leads to an interesting communicative possibility that crypto-tritheistic Christianity denies us – people subscribing to these memes can easily communicate their state of mind and emotions just by saying they were ‘possessed by anger’ (an idiom that persists today), or that ‘Coyote tricked them’ when they’ve done something particularly stupid that’s backfired on them badly. I am not certain, as I’m not too familiar with Catholicism2, but I imagine their saints work in similar ways (“the Virgin was watching out for my son”, “St. Christopher guided my steps”, etc).

However, this limitation of expression as imposed by a ‘single’ God was not necessarily a negative thing. No longer could you simply communicate a complex interior state thru a quick three or four words – you had to describe it in more detail, and thus have a more thorough understanding of what you were actually feeling. So monotheism may in fact have forced us to examine our interior lives more closely – always a good thing!

In a similar vein of moving from pantheism to monotheism, moving from monotheism to atheism provides a similar paradigm shift in outlook. Now instead of explaining physical events in terms of supernatural powers (“What a storm! God must be angry today!”), we again must look more closely at the phenomena and try to describe it in a different, more descriptive way (“Wow, that Arctic high really hit that warm front hard!”).

So much like neural pruning, a *lack* of other channels to express something leads to clearer and more sophisticated thought. Monotheism replacing pantheism may have contribued to more people living a richer and more introspective interior life, and in turn the move from monotheism to atheism similarly may have led to a richer and more rational interior life for people as well.


1 I’ve previously read of the notion of communicating one’s state by talking of being ‘possessed’ by one god or another representing an emotion or behaviour (“Soldier of Arete”, Gene Wolfe), which definitely inspired this post.

2 Despite it’s popularity I don’t think I’d classify Catholicism as strictly Christian; my readings of the Bible don’t seem to acknowledge any divinity or supernatural power other than the Trinity.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*